Top 5 Insomnia Products

Discover which supplement took home the Editor's Choice Award for an effective insomnia treatment. We understand how frustrating sleeplessness can be and the havoc it can wreak on your daily lives, so to help you get rid of your insomnia, we listed our top 5 insomnia remedies. To come up with our top choices, we evaluated hundreds of insomnia treatment options, from over-the-counter medicine, homeopathic options to all natural products. We listed them here in order of superiority, basing our research on the following criteria:

  • 1) Performance*
  • 2) Speed of Results*
  • 3) Quality of Ingredients
  • 4) Product Safety
  • 5) Customer Service
  • 6) Customer Feedback
  • 7) Reorder Rate
  • 8) Return Policy
  • 9) Success Rate

TOP 5

Insomnia Center Top 5 Rating

INSOMNIATreatments

InsoRelief ProHealth FibroSleep Best Health Sleep Dissolves Zen Life Supplements Zen Night Nutrition Breakthrough Sleep Minerals
1 2 3 4 5
Price (1 bottle)
Price (6 bottles) Best Value
$49.95
$139.80
$32.49
$194.94
$29.95
$179.70
$44.95
$149.94
$23.95
$160.65
Overall Rating 99.50% 87.30% 86.50% 78.90% 73.50%
Effectiveness
Speed of Results Extremely Fast Good Good Average Average
Quality of Ingredients Premium Good Good Good Average
Customer Satisfaction Evaluation 99.40% 85.30% 84% 76.20% 73%
Safety Evaluation Safe for Use Safe for Use Safe for Use Safe for Use Safe for Use
Customer Service Rating
Reorder Rate Highest Good Good Average Average
Return Policy Risk Free Risk Free Risk Free Risk Free Not Available
Success Rate 99.40% 87.10% 85.70% 78% 73.30%

Insomnia Products For 2024

#1 InsoRelief

Overall Rating: 99.1%

InsoRelief InsoRelief Learn More

Product Claims:

Our top recommendation for a supplement to help combat insomnia, is InsoRelief. This product is formulated from all natural ingredients which have been researched and clinically proven to provide the ultimate body support to aid restful sleep and overcome insomnia. InsoRelief is a product that works internally addressing elements that may cause sleepless nights, such as stress or anxiety, whilst also providing the optimal aid for inducing sleep, increasing duration and improving quality. This ultimate relaxing formula contains 11 clinically proven key ingredients for treating insomnia. These include: L-ornithine, valerian, hops, chamomile, magnolia, taurine, melatonin, reishi mushrooms, to name but a few. This unique blend provides a total care solution for overcoming sleep associated conditions. And what's more, there are no unwanted side effects from these all natural ingredients.

Value:

Along with the great all natural formula, InsoRelief offers real value in their package deals. InsoRelief extends savings of $220 if you order 6 bottles, this is an incredible, sensible, cost effective option. Positive customer feedback and testimonials demonstrate the huge numbers of satisfied customers with a 98% approval rate. This is very impressive. Consumers can feel very confident in this sleep aid product as it offers a 100% money back guarantee. InsoRelief is formulated in a laboratory that is both FDA-Approved and GMP certified. This means that the company is held to very strict standards and high-quality assurance.

Conclusion:

Of all the sleep remedies we tested, InsoRelief ranks the highest. Their formula has the most effective all natural ingredients and works more efficaciously than all the other products we tested. It also offers a money back guarantee and excellent customer service. With all this going for it, it’s no surprise that InsoRelief is the best product available for combatting insomnia and is Insomnia Center’s #1 choice.

Read Full Review >>

#2 ProHealth FibroSleep

Overall Rating: 78%

ProHealth FibroSleep ProHealth FibroSleep Learn More

Product Claims:

ProHealth FibroSleep came in a close second. It had the right idea to provide the wide range of ingredients it did in their formula. They included some key ingredients including melatonin, magnesium, hops and lemon balm. We did note that they also include a registered trademarked ingredient called Sedapine, which is fundamentally a proprietary blend of various natural ingredients. They claim that this product is ideal for those insomnia sufferers whose causes are the most common such as stress and anxiety.

Value:

We felt that price wise, ProHealth FibroSleep was pretty much on par with other similar products. We were happy to see that this supplier offers a 60-day money back guarantee. This is simple and straightforward providing consumers with the confidence to buy. They offer discounts once you become a member, but we felt that this was too similar to auto ship programs that we feel can take consumers for a ride! We say, read the small print.

Conclusion:

ProHealth FibroSleep was almost there with a top quality product but we felt that there were several key elements missing. We liked their inclusion of ‘Sedapine’ and the idea behind it, however, but it lacks clinical research to back up the benefits of this proprietary blend of ingredients. We also liked the fact that we found many positive reviews for this product, however, alarm bells rang slightly because, we only found positive reviews. Most supplements have a real mix of different consumer experiences so this raised a red flag. We also didnt like the terms and conditions of their membership program, we felt that it narrowed consumer buying choice. If they addressed these issues positively, we felt that this could have been a winner!

Read Full Review >>

#3 Best Health Sleep Dissolves

Overall Rating: 73.5%

Best Health Sleep Dissolves Best Health Sleep Dissolves Learn More

Product Claims:

Sleep Dissolves dietary supplement is manufactured by a company called Best Health. This product uses some good natural ingredients, that they claim can assist in falling asleep and staying asleep longer, as well as, resetting you sleep schedule. Sleep Dissolves contains a good blend of ingredients including melatonin and chamomile. They offer this product in an easy ‘melt blend’ (dissolving tablets) stating that they are easy for consumers to take. It is a 100% natural product. However, it does contain some extra ingredients that we felt were unnecessary - mannitol, sorbitol, microcrystalline cellulose, crospovidone, stearic acid, magnesium stearate, silica, and natural flavor.

Value:

We felt that Sleep Dissolves offered a good product but the price was slightly high when compared to others, especially given that they only provide 30 capsules in a bottle. They do offer a ‘Anytime’ guarantee which is a plus for consumers. In addition, they have several bulk discounts available for multi-purchase options, as well as, a price lock function, which means that once you have enrolled with them, you will always pay the same price as your first purchase. We did not find any customer reviews on their website. With all these amazing offers, we asked ourselves, why would this be? Perhaps, it is a relatively new product? Either way, we would like to have read some kind of feedback about how consumers found using this product.

Conclusion:

Sleep Dissolves offers several very positive elements. The ingredients are good quality and all natural providing active support for bringing on sleep and staying asleep. It would appear that the ‘melts’ are easy to take but without any real customer reviews we remain in the the dark on this. The fact they offer a strong money back guarantee, we felt, placed them in a strong position. Together, with the options of discount for multiple purchases and the money lock option, the price is on par with other similar products. However, if you want something short-term and would only like to purchase one bottle, this could be an expensive option.

Read Full Review >>

#4 Zen Life Supplements Zen Night

Overall Rating: 62.4%

Zen Life Supplements Zen Night Zen Life Supplements Zen Night Learn More

Product Claims:

Zen Life Supplements Zen Night is said to make you fall asleep within a few minutes and not to awaken during the night. Furthermore, this supplement will allow you to awaken refreshed and rested feeling energized throughout the day. The ingredients are all natural and include melatonin, valerian, chamomile, lemon balm and hops. Their formula is very similar to our top choice, however, it doesn’t contain L-ornithine which we felt set our #1 choice apart from the rest. Also, it contains several other inactive ingredients that raised some concerns - namely, gelatin, stearic acid, magnesium stearate and silica. We assume that these compose the capsule casing but are not entirely sure about this. That said, when we tested the ingredients in this product, they were as reported on the bottle.

Value:

We felt that the price for this product was OK but were concerned about how cheap it was on some websites. Our experience suggests that this could reflect the standard of the product, it could be that the quality of ingredients is poor and/or the dosage low so that they can price cut, however, this leaves consumers having to take more to reach an effective level. This can lead to all sorts of issues regarding overdosing, so for these reasons, until further testing can be carried out, we could not place this higher on our score board.

Conclusion:

With a lack of reviews, a formulation containing some questionable ingredients, low price indicative of poor quality perhaps and limited information about any side effects or dosing issues, we couldn't place this supplement any higher than in our # 4 ranking. Its redeeming features however, include the fact that they use all natural ingredients plus, the price is cheap, however, you might be taking a risk about the quality of the product.

Read Full Review >>

#5 Nutrition Breakthrough Sleep Minerals

Overall Rating: 61.5%

Nutrition Breakthrough Sleep Minerals Nutrition Breakthrough Sleep Minerals Learn More

Product Claims:

Our #5 pick is Nutrition Breakthroughs Sleep Minerals II, which the manufacturer claims has the ability to be rapidly absorbed into the body, as well as, many other health benefits to provide a deeper, longer lasting sleep experience. The ingredients are pure and include some excellent minerals and vitamins for improved health. However, we found that this supplement was lacking many key clinically proven ingredients beneficial for combatting insomnia. It has a long list of ingredients, which look good on the bottle, but when we actually visited each one, we were left wondering about why some of them had been included. We did like the fact that it contained no additives, fillers or binders but did note that it includes beeswax and soy, which some people may be allergic to.

Value:

The price is relatively cheap and its bottle contains 120 softgels. However, the formula needs a little tweaking to successfully fight insomnia by including clinically proven ingredients specific to combat those sleepless nights. We were unable to find a specific company guarantee, but if you purchase through Amazon, then you have their own guarantee. We were unable to find any reviews for this product which left us wondering how effective it really is, which was a shame.

Conclusion:

This product contains some good ingredients known to assist in improving our general health, however, we would like to have seen some consumer reviews to better understand how effective this product really is. Overall, we felt that it would need to introduce some more effective key ingredients that have been clinically proven to addresses root causes of insomnia, as well as, deal with the frustrating symptoms of not being able to get to sleep or stay asleep, to get a higher grade. Together with its lack of money back guarantee we had to place this at the bottom of our list.

Read Full Review >>